22 Comments
User's avatar
Gaye's avatar

These people should not be in the “education” business, and science/health in particular. “When this virus is over, ignorance will still be contagious, and distancing from those who spread it will still be in order.” —The Ethical Skeptic

Expand full comment
Sarah's avatar

But if we get Tom DeVore elected as AG. Maybe people will start to be accountable

I hosted an awake Illinois meeting at the beginning of the school year last year , and one guest said we must sue the IDPH for there polices. I now realize she’s right ! It’s the ISBE the IDPH and the schools.

We have to maintain hope there will be accountability. I’m anxious for November elections. I won’t lose hope before a November!

Expand full comment
Jessica Hockett's avatar

Ideally, we wouldn’t have to sue, but I agree that in the absence of a moral legislature, it’s the way.

Expand full comment
Arne's avatar

Getting suspended by Twitter wasn't in your plans, I have to figure, but it's easier to understand these kinds of problems when the relevant material is presented here, than when it's presented in a series of tweets.

Expand full comment
Mmbjt's avatar

If I’m reading this correctly then every person who quarantined without and IDPH order has a lawsuit. Correct?

Expand full comment
Jessica Hockett's avatar

That’s my reading of the law & administrative code as well.

INAL and welcome other opinions that cite the law.

Expand full comment
Lyma's avatar

2 summers ago there were open riots in the streets, and congress is focused on a 1/6 show trial. There won’t be legal consequence, because there is a 2-tiered legal system, neither of which can support this case. (Reference - https://youtu.be/z6faVQcFNrk)

Expand full comment
Sarah's avatar

My unvaccinated son with Autism was put into quarantine because of exposure so many times last year. We requested he repeat 7th grade. He’s vaccinated peers remained at school when exposed. Clearly intimidation and discrimination from IDPH and he school to push covid vaccines and masks. Since it is a private Christian school there is not much I can do. But I’m praying daily public schools are held accountable

Expand full comment
Heather's avatar

A little background on the local scene.

In June 2020 the administrator of the Champaign County Public Health attended a protest.

“ A lot of people are dealing with uncertainty and fear for the first time during the pandemic. We are out here in solidarity with people who live that everyday,” Pryde said. “People are fed up.”

She acknowledged that she is concerned the protests and reopening of businesses may lead to outbreaks of COVID-19. Pryde says the public health district is a resource for those who become ill, and that they’re ramping up their contact tracing capabilities.”

https://illinoisnewsroom.org/hundreds-protest-peacefully-in-urbana-champaign-in-response-to-killing-of-george-floyd/

Expand full comment
Jessica Hockett's avatar

Someone needs to teach her about the law and about a little something called “differential risk”.

Expand full comment
James O'Reilly's avatar

Perhaps students should sue.

Expand full comment
Jessica Hockett's avatar

Someone should reach out to Xavier Josephs…

Expand full comment
Sarah's avatar

IDPH should be held accountable for giving guidelines that discriminate against unvaccinated people , especially children. And the schools who volunteered to follow these guidelines should be legally held accountable too.

Expand full comment
Jessica Hockett's avatar

Yes to all that.

Masks (which are a kind of modified quarantine under IL law) were bad enough. But the damages from forced unlawful quarantines of healthy children are mammoth and easy to prove.

Expand full comment
Lyma's avatar

Nobody will ever be held accountable - the system is far more broken than realized, and it won’t let responsibility damage itself.

Expand full comment
Andy's avatar

This is one of several tragic suicides on campus in the last 2.5 years, as a result of the student being put in "isolation/quarantine". Students were treated horribly. Force to move to quarantine-designated dorms, with little contact from anyone during the isolation period. https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/suburban-college-student-dies-by-suicide-after-struggling-with-isolation/2392878/

Expand full comment
Jessica Hockett's avatar

Correct.

This student's mother was one of four parents who filed a lawsuit against Governor Prtizker's unlawful executive orders and needless mitigations related to teens, schools, and sports.

https://chicago.suntimes.com/high-school-sports/2020/12/23/22196848/pritzker-lawsuit-ihsa-winter-high-school-sports#:~:text=Monday%20against%20Gov.-,J.B.,of%20the%20State%20of%20Illinois

I don't know the status of the suit, but it seems the mom & other U of I parents/students should speak to a lawyer about the legality of the quarantines issued by CUPHD (with the school's assistance/endorsement).

Expand full comment
Michael Carter's avatar

You wrote, "Someone with legal standing, money, and guts might be able to hold these Illinois entities — and many more — accountable." I keep hoping some legal association will take some students and/or employees up on this and get some lawsuits going. Common sense, laws, lots of good data, and rules continue to be ignored. In the USA it seems that many of these institutions need to be hit in the pocketbook to see the light.

Expand full comment
Jessica Hockett's avatar

Yes, I’m hoping for the same.

Statements like this one (from the Sept 2, 2020 MassMail to undergrads) were patently false:

“If you receive a call from Champaign-Urbana Public Health District (beginning with a 217 or 312 area code), respond immediately and follow their guidance about quarantine and isolation. If you don’t, you will be in violation of state law, and you will be suspended from the university.”

CUPDH wasn’t following the law, nor was U of I. Seems like a 14th amendment federal suit could be filed, as well as a suit in state court.

Expand full comment
Michael Carter's avatar

This is infuriating and I think we will see ill effects for a long time. Please publicize any legal action you see. I would be happy to contribute to this kind of thing. I'm sure others would as well. Thank you for all your work on substack and on twitter.

Expand full comment
Ann Fredericks's avatar

Someone needs to sue

Expand full comment
Lyma's avatar

Why? Because they know they can discriminate against wealthy elites and their children. They’ve written a 2nd secret constitution that you don’t have access to (https://youtu.be/-P2bDgwvv2E), and it is now applied to healthcare.

Expand full comment